India gets Modi lift as other BRICs struggle
Goldman Sachs this week announced the closure of its dedicated BRIC (Brazil, Russia, China and India) fund after nearly 10 years. The move signalled the end of the BRIC era, as this year saw recessions plague Russia and Brazil while growth in China stalled.
Neil Mehta, Markit
India, however, has remained a bright spot, and the performance of its government bonds highlights this. Over the past two years, Indian government bonds have returned 25% on a total return basis, according to Markit’s iBoxx indices. Conversely, BRIC peers have lagged with Chinese government bonds returning only 14% over the same period. Brazilian government bond returns were on par with that of India in June this year, but a slump in commodity prices and political turmoil in Brazil sent returns diverging.
The stability of Indian government bond returns over the past two years signals investors’ confidence. Having largely avoided any external shocks, India has remained fiscally prudent while providing robust growth. The period has also coincided with a rise in power of the current prime minister Narendra Modi, known for his progressive economic agendas.
Since Modi started gaining traction in late 2013, investors have flocked to Indian corporate bonds. The basis between the Markit iBoxx USD Corporates India index spread and the Markit iBoxx USD Emerging Markets Corporates Overall index spread fell from 33bp to minus 38bp leading up to his election win in May 2014.
This highlights the positive reaction from bond investors in the wake of the Modi election. Indian corporates then further outperformed emerging markets in 2014, partly due to being insulated against commodity price shocks. However, the basis has flattened over the last eight months, suggesting a stall in the post Modi rally.
India’s CDS hit 190bp in September, 23bp wider than where it was trading at the start of the year. It has since recovered, and India’s performance in comparison to the other BRICs still looks impressive.
Nonetheless, Modi faces significant challenges in implementing his planned economic reforms. The task was made harder last week when his party was comprehensively beaten in state elections in Bihar. Credibility abroad is also of key concern if Modi cannot reign in nonconformist members of his party.
Investors have been quick to react to the brewing political tensions. ETFs tracking Indian assets saw $1.2bn of outflows in the third quarter, the highest amount in five years and the first negative outflow quarter of the Modi era. Investors have also stayed away in the current quarter so far, as investment sentiment wanes in the world’s largest democracy.