SEC needs a derivatives sanity check
GlobalCapital, is part of the Delinian Group, DELINIAN (GLOBALCAPITAL) LIMITED, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 15236213
Copyright © DELINIAN (GLOBALCAPITAL) LIMITED and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

SEC needs a derivatives sanity check

The US Securities and Exchange Commission has a chance to examine its conscience over plans to curb derivatives use. It should do so after the industry condemned a sweeping approach that revealed little comprehension of the many sensible interactions that exist between derivatives and everyday capital markets.

It’s a good job that the SEC is line for a bigger budget from October. It will need this just to go through the complaints it receives if it carries on proposing ideas like the Derivative Rules for Registered Funds and Business Development Companies.

The tide of dissent has been no flash of mob outrage either, but a painstaking and detailed deconstruction of the SEC's plans and their objectives that make a compelling case for thorough revision. Similarly, token generic warnings about the dangers of modern finance from the rule's few friends might give the SEC reason to wonder why its proposal has attracted support from some of the least informed market participants.

The rules as they stand would have the counterproductive effect of heightening capital market risks by limiting portfolio diversification and making it harder for investors to manage their exposures. It is time for the SEC to show that it values consultation, is susceptible to rational argument and recognises that derivatives aren’t traded independently but in concert with cash assets, allowing users to transfer unwanted risks and manage capital. 

The SEC sits on an arsenal of information that will allow it to fashion an approach which is not too broadly prescriptive, that recognises the nuances of how derivatives work and the different functions they serve.

In short it can do better than rules that aren’t needed, with arbitrary limits, in order to protect people who don’t need (and don’t want) to be protected. 

Related articles

  • SSA

    Agencies sharpen tactics in year of the yield grab

    The pace of issuance from agency issuers has been remarkable this year as investors’ renewed love affair with fixed income heats up. But there are still challenges to getting deals done, meaning borrowers must come up with new ways to keep funding ticking over, writes Georgie Lee
  • SSA

    Sovereigns reach retail inflection point

    Savvy government issuers have been able to fund record volumes from retail investors since interest rates began to rise, which contributed to tighter spreads, even as debt-to-GDP ratios increased. But where next now that banks have caught up, the ECB has cut rates and household liquidity has receded? Georgie Lee investigates
  • SSA

    Supras learn to change in changing world

    Multilateral development banks find themselves swept up in two parallel waves of change. As bond issuers, they are having to deftly navigate capital markets that are still emerging from the end of years of historically low rates, being forced to call upon all their experience and sophistication as they fund across multiple markets. At the same time, with the pressure on to fill the huge gap in global development finance, these institutions are being asked to work out how to better use or expand their balance sheets and lend more — all while maintaining their precious credit ratings. GlobalCapital gathered some of the leading supranational issuers at a roundtable in New York City in May to discuss how best to deal with the challenges of this changing world.
  • SSA

    No easy wins in development bank power-up

    There has never been so much momentum to reform the multilateral development banks. But most of the many avenues to expand their lending have run into difficulties. Jon Hay reports
  • SSA

    ‘Big leap forward’ needed to propel EU to safe asset status

    For those hoping that the EU, with its swollen borrowing programme since the pandemic, could become a common European safe asset, the wait may take a little longer as the issuer works to establish itself as a sovereign-like entity and the bloc struggles to make progress on Capital Markets Union. Addison Gong reports
  • Battle-hardened Karofsky leaves IB field for assault on top job

    Outgoing head of UBS Investment Bank has steered it through tumultuous times
Gift this article