Star board: a roller coaster ride to remember

The first 25 companies that started trading on the new Shanghai tech board on Monday skyrocketed, as Chinese investors welcomed the Nasdaq-style equity market with frenzied trading. As the excitement cooled on Tuesday, the bourse’s performance shows that regulators must not just focus on market reform, but also on market participants.

  • By Rebecca Feng
  • 23 Jul 2019
Email a colleague
Request a PDF

The Star Market, a new board aimed at revolutionising China’s onshore stock market and drawing technology firms back to the country, opened with a boom on Monday. While it is normal for a company’s stock price to pop on its debut, the performance of some of the maiden stocks on Star was a whole different story.

By the end of the first trading day, the 25 names experienced an average stock price increase of 140%. The top gainer, Anji Microelectronics, spiked at a jaw-dropping 400% from its offering price. Even the company with the smallest jump, Harbin Xinguang Optic-Electronics Technology, boasted a 84% increase in its share price.

This would have been less shocking had these companies listed on China’s main A–share market, where offering prices have been capped at 23 times earnings by the China Securities Regulatory Commission since 2014.

With no such limits on the Star, the stocks on the bourse are in no way cheap. At the time of pricing, some investors were spooked by the issuers’ high price to earnings ratios. The 25 IPOs were priced anywhere from 18.86 times earnings for state-owned China Railway Signal and Communication to a lofty 170.75 times earnings for semiconductor manufacturer Advanced Micro-Fabrication Equipment. On average, the PE ratio reached 49.16 times.

It is natural to expect limited upside growth for Star companies given their high valuations. Analysts both onshore and offshore expected most stocks to rise 20%-40%, with a turnover of around 35%-65%.

But they underestimated institutional investors’ willingness to practice, and succeed in, what they repeatedly do in the A–share market — push stock prices high and sell them to hungry retail investors and funds that did not get any pre-IPO shares.

Monday’s performance spoke volumes. One company halted trading after one minute after its price increased more than 30%, and six more halted trading within five minutes for the same reason. But as stock prices kept rising throughout the day, institutional investors started selling.

By the end of Monday, the average turnover of the 25 stocks reached 78%, meaning most investors with pre-IPO shares sold them in the market. At least five equity traders and asset managers told GlobalRMB or the local media that they would not return anytime soon. The accumulated market cap of the Star board reached Rmb538.8bn ($78bn) and four dollar billionaires were born, although most of them will likely lose that title fairly soon.

Tuesday was a slightly different story though. Twenty-one of the 25 stocks saw their prices drop. Fourteen slumped by more than 10%, and the average turnover rate shrank to 36%.

The regulators have few choices now. They have made promises, time and again in the 259 days since Chinese president Xi Jinping first brought up the idea for a tech board, to make the Star Market fully market driven with a transparent price discovery process. Currently, the Star board has no daily limits for the first five days and after that has a more lenient 20% daily limit gain or drop, compared with 10% for the A–share market. It also allows investors to short-sell on the first day of trading, a practice forbidden elsewhere in the country until three months after a stock’s debut.

The feverish excitement seen among Star investors so far is unsustainable. To avoid getting their fingers burnt, a less opportunistic approach would be wise.

More importantly, this week’s two hectic days of trading provided an important lesson. Having a mature market with less stringent rules is one thing, but equally necessary is having a mature investor base. China’s Star Market needs to be able to walk before it can run.

  • By Rebecca Feng
  • 23 Jul 2019

Panda Bonds Top Arrangers

Rank Arranger Share % by Volume
1 Bank of China (BOC) 27.09
2 Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) 12.86
3 China Merchants Bank Co 11.85
4 China Merchants Securities Co 9.09
5 Agricultural Bank of China (ABC) 5.51

Bookrunners of Asia-Pac (ex-Japan) ECM

Rank Lead Manager Amount $b No of issues Share %
  • Last updated
  • Today
1 CITIC Securities 15.74 76 7.79%
2 Goldman Sachs 14.46 60 7.16%
3 China International Capital Corp Ltd 14.21 72 7.03%
4 UBS 12.70 89 6.28%
5 Morgan Stanley 11.11 66 5.50%

Bookrunners of Asia Pacific (ex-Japan) G3 DCM

Rank Lead Manager Amount $b No of issues Share %
  • Last updated
  • Today
1 HSBC 32.35 286 8.25%
2 Citi 25.59 178 6.53%
3 JPMorgan 18.14 134 4.63%
4 Standard Chartered Bank 18.08 182 4.61%
5 Bank of America Merrill Lynch 15.32 112 3.91%

Asian polls & awards

  • Finance Minister of the Year, CEE

    Djamshid Kuchkarov, Uzbekistan

  • GlobalCapital China Capital Market Awards 2019: open for submissions

    GlobalCapital China is pleased to invite you to participate in the GlobalCapital China Capital Market Awards 2019. Inaugurated last year under the GlobalRMB banner, the awards celebrate the accomplishments of the leading players in the renminbi debt capital markets, onshore and offshore, as well as key service providers.

  • Last chance! GlobalCapital Asia Capital Market Awards 2019

    GlobalCapital Asia is pleased to invite pitches for our annual capital markets and investment banking awards, which reward the most impressive transactions and investment banks of 2019.

  • GlobalCapital reveals SRI Award nominations

    GlobalCapital has published the nominations for its Sustainable and Responsible Capital Markets Awards. The winners will be announced on September 17, at our Awards Ceremony in Amsterdam.

  • GlobalCapital SRI Awards: poll extended

    In response to requests from market participants, GlobalCapital has extended the closing date of its poll to determine the 2019 winners of its Sustainable and Responsible Capital Markets Awards. Market participants can now vote until July 26.