Shrinking sales, high borrowing costs challenge Chinese developers, say experts

The slowdown in sales and rising onshore yields will be two headwinds for Chinese property developers in 2018, industry experts told the Euromoney China Property and Consumption Investment Summit on December 6.

  • By Noah Sin
  • 07 Dec 2017
Email a colleague
Request a PDF

Soaring home ownership has become one of the hallmarks of China’s remarkable growth story – the liberalisation of a run-down economy which brought millions from rags to riches in just three decades.

But real estate prices have surged fast enough in recent years that the government can no longer afford to allow the sector to crash – even as it seeks to squeeze out speculators in the market, said Shuang Ding, chief economist for Greater China and North Asia at Standard Chartered.

“The property sector has become too big to fail,” he said. “It directly accounts for about 10% of China’s GDP. In terms of contribution to GDP growth, real estate and sectors related to it account for about one third.”

A slowdown in the sector will not only put pressure on economic growth but also shake the financial sector, which is deleveraging following a long period of balance sheet expansion.

“A correction in property prices will have an impact on financial stability,” he said. “Loans to property sector is about a quarter of China’s total loan outstanding. Banks’ exposure to this sector also includes shadow banking. They have also used properties as collateral when extending loans.”

However, as sales in the property sector slowed down in the past year, economic growth was not significantly affected, said James MacDonald, head of research at Savills. He reckons this is a new phenomenon in the Chinese economy – and an opportunity for the government to rebalance the economy.

“We may be starting to get to a point where other drivers [other than real estate] are supporting the economy,” he said. “This may give the government more flexibility in terms of implementing regulations on the property market.”

Borrowing costs

Chinese property developers are also pressured by rising borrowing costs in the onshore debt market. Triple A rated three and five year Chinese corporate bonds were trading at 5.2330% and 5.3056% as of December 5, up from 3.6627% and 3.7633% a year earlier, Wind data shows.

To their dismay, developers may not have seen the end of this upward trajectory yet, said Franco Leung, senior credit officer for Corporate Finance Group at Moody’s.

He noted that many issuers have sold bonds which with a put option after three years, should investors choose not to extend the bond for two years with a new coupon. With onshore liquidity remaining tight, investors are likely to put the bonds issued by smaller developers, even if they are offered at relatively attractive coupons.

“It is likely that there will be an increase in average borrowing cost, with onshore bonds extended with high coupons,” said Leung.

Nevertheless, as long as growth in real estate sales continues – albeit at a slower pace – the bond market still offers developers the best option to raise funds, said Paddy Ran, portfolio manager at China Life Franklin Asset Management.

“Most developers can raise a bond lasting three to five year at 3%-6%,” he said. “That is very cheap funding compared to the double-digit growth they can achieve onshore in contract sales.”

  • By Noah Sin
  • 07 Dec 2017

Panda Bonds Top Arrangers

Rank Arranger Share % by Volume
1 China Merchants Securities Co 22.39
2 CITIC Securities 13.39
3 Agricultural Bank of China (ABC) 12.17
3 Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) 12.17
5 China CITIC Bank Corp 10.95

Bookrunners of Asia-Pac (ex-Japan) ECM

Rank Lead Manager Amount $m No of issues Share %
  • Last updated
  • Today
1 Goldman Sachs 12,347.28 50 8.27%
2 Citi 10,937.22 60 7.33%
3 Morgan Stanley 9,836.89 36 6.59%
4 China International Capital Corp Ltd 7,946.42 27 5.33%
5 China Securities Co Ltd 7,436.55 29 4.98%

Bookrunners of Asia Pacific (ex-Japan) G3 DCM

Rank Lead Manager Amount $m No of issues Share %
  • Last updated
  • Today
1 HSBC 15,269.13 121 7.26%
2 Citi 14,283.19 91 6.80%
3 JPMorgan 10,369.33 52 4.93%
4 Bank of America Merrill Lynch 9,897.67 56 4.71%
5 Goldman Sachs 9,025.15 40 4.29%

Asian polls & awards

  • GlobalCapital opens Green/SRI Bond and Loan Awards Poll 2018

    After a year of burgeoning growth and change in green, social and sustainability bond issuance, with huge acceleration in green loans, GlobalCapital today invites you to vote in its third Awards poll for this market.

  • The Australian Fixed Income Poll 2018

    Asiamoney, in association with National Australia Bank, invites all fixed income investors in Asia and Europe to participate in the Australian Fixed Income Poll 2018. The online poll will take only five to 10 minutes to complete.

  • Regional Capital Markets Awards Part IV: Investment Bank

    In the last instalment of our 2017 awards, we present the full write-ups of the winners of Best Asian Investment Bank and Best Investment Bank.

  • Regional Capital Markets Awards Part III: Bonds

    In the third instalment of our 2017 awards, we present the full write-ups of the winners of the Best Local Currency Bond, Best High Yield Bond, Best Financial Bond, Best SSA Bond, Best Investment Grade Bond, Best Project Finance Deal, Best Bond, Best G3 and Local Currency Bond House, and Best High Yield Bond House.

  • Regional Capital Markets Awards Part II: Equities

    In the second instalment of our 2017 awards, we present the full write-ups of the winners for Best Follow-On/Accelerated Bookbuild, Best Equity-Linked Deal, Best IPO, Best ECM Deal and Best ECM House.