Chinese property bonds: still the golden goose?

Investors have mixed feelings about bonds from Chinese property companies, but a likely supply-demand rebalance could signal yet another honeymoon period for the sector.

  • By Addison Gong
  • 09 Oct 2019
Email a colleague
Request a PDF

Chinese property bonds are going through a rough period. Concerns around a toughened policy stance from regulators, the overwhelming year-to-date primary supply and broader market sentiment shifts have caused some investors to distance themselves from the sector.

As a result, dollar bonds from China Evergrande Group, Fantasia Holdings Group, Golden Wheel Tiandi Holdings, Modern Land China Co and Xinyuan Real Estate are trading around the low 90s or even well into the 80s in the secondary market. Even lower beta names with investment grade ratings, such as China Jinmao Holdings Group and Sino Ocean Land, have widened by 30bp-50bp in recent weeks.

The sector is also seeing more divergence. The spread differential between single-B and double-B rated names widened to 240bp by the end of September, according to JP Morgan.

In new issues, a shift from a seller’s market to a buyer’s market has forced Beijing Hongkun Weiye Real Estate Development Co, Fujian Yango Group, Helenbergh China Holdings and Zensun Group to offer yields of between 12.5% and 14.75% for relatively short-dated bonds.

The worries and the fatigue are justifiable. Cracks in the Chinese property market are showing amid a moderation in the country’s economic growth. This is as regulators, including the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC), tighten the financing environment for the sector both on and offshore, putting refinancing risk back in the spotlight. 

Issuers have raced to raise debt this year in a market that is already oversupplied. Chinese developers collectively printed a record $60bn of dollar bonds during the first nine months of 2019, almost 40% higher than the full-year 2018 issuance from the sector.

Naturally, that excess supply has put investors in dire need of diversification away from property names and, to some extent, Chinese bonds.

But the property bond market is far from broken. Among international deals from the country, real estate is still the most understood — and arguably, the most predictable — sector, and it comes with attractive yields. While the historical spread premium for Asian bonds has compressed over the years, Chinese high yield property bonds that were included in the JP Morgan Asia Credit Index were still trading at least 386bp wide of similarly rated US comparables as of late September, according to the bank’s research desk.

More importantly, a slowdown in the pace of new issues from this quarter is foreseeable. Deal flow has already started to become more disciplined since the NDRC’s move in July to limit the use of proceeds from property bonds to strictly offshore refinancing, triggering a likely rebalance between supply and demand.

Adding to the equation are two other things. Cheap onshore funding conditions this year have kept international issuance from state-owned enterprises and financial institutions largely at bay, while high yield industrial credits and bonds from non-Chinese borrowers have continued to be sporadic.

That, coupled with a similar issuance restriction on local government financing vehicles — another important segment of the dollar bond market in Asia — means investors will likely be willing to take whatever bonds come their way, especially if it’s from a quality name.

As distinctions between the good and the weak credits continue to become clearer, defaults may be inevitable. But investors will also find more buying opportunities — so long as they don’t write off property bonds just yet.

  • By Addison Gong
  • 09 Oct 2019

Panda Bonds Top Arrangers

Rank Arranger Share % by Volume
1 Bank of China (BOC) 18.86
2 Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) 14.39
3 China Merchants Bank Co 14.21
4 China Merchants Securities Co 8.85
5 Agricultural Bank of China (ABC) 5.90

Bookrunners of Asia-Pac (ex-Japan) ECM

Rank Lead Manager Amount $bn No of issues Share %
  • Last updated
  • Today
1 China International Capital Corp Ltd 4.57 23 12.72%
2 China Securities Co Ltd 3.53 7 9.82%
3 Morgan Stanley 3.39 11 9.42%
4 CITIC Securities 3.29 11 9.16%
5 Goldman Sachs 1.70 13 4.74%

Bookrunners of Asia Pacific (ex-Japan) G3 DCM

Rank Lead Manager Amount $bn No of issues Share %
  • Last updated
  • Today
1 Citi 7.00 39 7.60%
2 HSBC 5.95 51 6.46%
3 UBS 4.47 29 4.85%
4 BofA Securities 4.36 17 4.73%
5 JPMorgan 4.28 28 4.65%

Asian polls & awards

  • GlobalCapital China 2019 awards winners: Part III

    In the final part of GlobalCapital China’s awards announcement, we discuss the key innovation of 2019, and reveal the individual that has made the greatest contribution to reforming and internationalising the Chinese onshore market.

  • GlobalCapital China 2019 awards winners: Part II

    In the second part of GlobalCapital China’s awards announcement, we reveal the winning banks across Panda bonds, G3 bonds and ABS, as well as the best bank for securities services and the most impressive law firm.

  • GlobalCapital Asia capital markets awards 2019: Investment banks

    In the fourth and final instalment of GlobalCapital Asia’s capital markets awards announcements, find out which firms have been named the Best Asian Investment Bank and the Best Investment Bank in the region for 2019.

  • GlobalCapital China announces 2019 awards winners: Part I

    GlobalCapital China, previously GlobalRMB, is pleased to announce the winners of its annual capital markets awards, honouring the banks, companies and individuals that have made the biggest contribution to bridging the gap between China’s markets and the rest of the world. In part one of the awards, we reveal the most impressive issuers in the FIG, corporate and SSA categories.

  • GlobalCapital Asia capital markets awards 2019: Bonds

    In part three of GlobalCapital Asia's awards results announcements, we reveal the winning bond deals across a variety of categories. In addition, we also name the Best G3 Bond House, Best High Yield Bond House and the winner of the Best House for SRI Financing.