China needs to stop making small talk

The Chinese government is starting to sound like a broken record by repeating over and over again that there is nothing to fear from the continued depreciation of the renminbi. But with the currency hitting an eight-year low against the dollar, it’s time for Beijing to provide some genuine guidance before the markets stop listening for good.

  • By Rev Hui
  • 15 Nov 2016
Email a colleague
Request a PDF

Be careful what you wish for. After last year’s shock reform of the renminbi fixing mechanism in August, market participants were complaining about China’s lack of communication.

Well, China clearly took notice. Ever since that fiasco, Beijing has been very quick to respond whenever there are large movements in the renminbi or volatility-inducing events such as Brexit.

Having public bodies or officials make a statement can help soothe investor concerns, especially when markets are jittery. In fact, such actions should be applauded especially in China where the authorities aren’t really known for being the most open communicators, as GlobalRMB has pointed out in the past.

But as so often is the case, China and the market were at cross purposes.

While it’s commendable that the Chinese regulators are ready to comment on the renminbi and global volatility, they also need to understand an essential part of communication — the need to be informative.

For example, the People’s Bank of China put out a statement at the start of the month explaining that the renminbi is relatively stable against the basket of currencies it tracks, in spite of continued weakness against the dollar.

The latter, it was keen to stress, was mostly due to broad dollar strength against most EM currencies. Simply put, it wants to markets view the situation as a dollar strengthening story, not a RMB depreciating one.

There would be nothing wrong with this if it was a new line of guidance, but this is basically the same message it has been putting out since the start of the year. See herehere and here.

While it is true that perhaps the market should not be so fixated on the dollar’s movement, the greenback is kind of difficult to ignore thanks to its status as the most important currency in the world. Not to mention the fact that the renminbi has lost over 5% against the dollar since the start of the year.

The PBoC has yet to comment on the bout of RMB weakness that followed Trump’s victory in the US presidential election. But, even if it did, we can make an educated guess as to what the gist is likely to be.

As one economist pointed, China’s argument is basically that other than sustained depreciation, there is no basis for sustained depreciation.

This is an issue China needs to fix.

While it is true the market has asked for more communication, simply repeating the same message again and again is not good enough. What the market needs is a clearer sense of the policy direction in the messages it gives out. Now that would be something to talk about. 

  • By Rev Hui
  • 15 Nov 2016

Panda Bonds Top Arrangers

Rank Arranger Share % by Volume
1 Bank of China (BOC) 18.86
2 Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) 14.39
3 China Merchants Bank Co 14.21
4 China Merchants Securities Co 8.85
5 Agricultural Bank of China (ABC) 5.90

Bookrunners of Asia-Pac (ex-Japan) ECM

Rank Lead Manager Amount $bn No of issues Share %
  • Last updated
  • Today
1 China International Capital Corp Ltd 4.57 23 12.72%
2 China Securities Co Ltd 3.53 7 9.82%
3 Morgan Stanley 3.39 11 9.42%
4 CITIC Securities 3.29 11 9.16%
5 Goldman Sachs 1.70 13 4.74%

Bookrunners of Asia Pacific (ex-Japan) G3 DCM

Rank Lead Manager Amount $bn No of issues Share %
  • Last updated
  • Today
1 Citi 7.00 39 7.60%
2 HSBC 5.95 51 6.46%
3 UBS 4.47 29 4.85%
4 BofA Securities 4.36 17 4.73%
5 JPMorgan 4.28 28 4.65%

Asian polls & awards

  • GlobalCapital China 2019 awards winners: Part III

    In the final part of GlobalCapital China’s awards announcement, we discuss the key innovation of 2019, and reveal the individual that has made the greatest contribution to reforming and internationalising the Chinese onshore market.

  • GlobalCapital China 2019 awards winners: Part II

    In the second part of GlobalCapital China’s awards announcement, we reveal the winning banks across Panda bonds, G3 bonds and ABS, as well as the best bank for securities services and the most impressive law firm.

  • GlobalCapital Asia capital markets awards 2019: Investment banks

    In the fourth and final instalment of GlobalCapital Asia’s capital markets awards announcements, find out which firms have been named the Best Asian Investment Bank and the Best Investment Bank in the region for 2019.

  • GlobalCapital China announces 2019 awards winners: Part I

    GlobalCapital China, previously GlobalRMB, is pleased to announce the winners of its annual capital markets awards, honouring the banks, companies and individuals that have made the biggest contribution to bridging the gap between China’s markets and the rest of the world. In part one of the awards, we reveal the most impressive issuers in the FIG, corporate and SSA categories.

  • GlobalCapital Asia capital markets awards 2019: Bonds

    In part three of GlobalCapital Asia's awards results announcements, we reveal the winning bond deals across a variety of categories. In addition, we also name the Best G3 Bond House, Best High Yield Bond House and the winner of the Best House for SRI Financing.