Many fixed-income professionals are not convinced that newly annointed nationally recognized statistic rating organization (NRSRO) Dominion Bond Rating Service, which has 41 analysts compared to 800 at Moody's Investors Service and 1000 at Standard & Poor's, will be a factor in the market. Tom Parker, a high-yield portfolio manager at Barclays Global Investors, argues that the ratings agencies have run into trouble in recent years because they judge the creditworthiness of a company according to its market cap. Enron and WorldCom proved that bigger is not better when an economic bubble bursts and you don't have any earnings, he says. "How does Dominion change this? The answer is it doesn't," Parker says. "The agencies still have the same problem. How do you adjust to an environment where size isn't the key variable? Adding five other independent ratings agencies doesn't change that either."
March 02, 2003