• Home
  • Home
  • Daily Papers
  • Awards / Events
  • GlobalCapital
  • Free Trial
Close

Copying and distributing are prohibited without permission of the publisher.

Watermark
  • Print

Resource-rich countries to clamp down on abuses

By Jon Marks
13 Oct 2012

Fragile African resources producers could work together to get a better deal from big corporations, Claire Short, chair of the EITI, said

International efforts to clamp down on bad deals struck with resource-rich but fragile developing economies are starting to make an impact, according to a range of stakeholders canvassed by Emerging Markets.

But some of them warned implementation was still spotty and that multilateral institutions could do more to force transparency onto powerful corporates and reluctant governments.

Clare Short, chair of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI), said fragile African resources producers could work together to get a better deal from corporate giants.

EITI’s 19 African member governments “should perhaps link up to give a stronger response”, confronted by companies who “hide dubious business practices and contract terms behind client confidentiality,” the former British development minister told Emerging Markets.

More governments – such as new oil producer Uganda – should sign up to EITI, which commits resources producers to publishing details of their income flows and corporates to declare all revenues they pay to the government, she said.

Ugandan MP Remigio Achia agreed that was necessary. “We still don’t get anything like sufficient detail of contracts to scrutinize the revenues,” she said. Achia, who is deputy chairman of the parliament’s budget committee, complained that lack of data and scrutiny opened producer governments to “transfer pricing” and tax avoidance.

Another problem is the weakness of some administrations relative to the size of the companies. “A lot of [developing country] tax administrations are not strong enough to tackle these big [oil and mining] companies,” Short said. “There is some transparency out there, but there is still some bad practice out there too, it’s a mixed picture,” she said.

Uganda’s Finance Minister Maria Kiwanuka said the prescriptions were well known but that the implementation was the critical issue. “We can’t say we don’t have all the information,” she said.

Daniel Balint-Kurti of resource transparency campaigners Global Witness told Emerging Markets that policy makers must make development aid conditional on transparency and anti-corruption measures, both on the level of policy and in practical terms. “Donors, including the World Bank and IMF, should apply pressure to make basic governance measures such as tenders and revenue transparency obligatory.”

IMF deputy managing director Naoyuki Shinohara agreed that “more capacity-building is needed”, to reinforce transparency. “We have to think about what the IMF can do,” he told a seminar this week.

Adding to the pressure is Dodd-Frank legislation in the US, which includes measures obliging companies to publish what they pay and check their supply chains to exclude conflict minerals. The European Union is now considering its own version of Dodd-Frank.

The controversial US legislation became active only in August, when the Securities and Exchange Commission published implementation regulations.

Governance expert Paul Collier said Dodd-Frank could have an impact, but it should be widened to other countries. Canada’s plethora of registered resources companies do not have similar standards to meet.

Collier, who is the architect of the Natural Resources Charter, said that it was time for the G8 to act in order have a global impact. The G8 forum was relevant, he said, because even with China’s rise, its member countries are “still where the majority of resources companies are based”.

Global Witness this week published recommendations to enshrine “transparent and accountable management” into revisions to Democratic Republic of Congo’s mining and oil codes.

By Jon Marks
13 Oct 2012
  • HOME
  • GLOBALMARKETS
  • Latest news from GlobalMarkets

    1. EM debt pressures build as IMF calls for ‘early’ action on restructuring

      15 Oct 2020
    2. Post-Covid world will demand ‘new more humane’ capitalism

      15 Oct 2020
    3. IADB to roll out hurricane clauses as small state pleas gain traction

      15 Oct 2020
    4. IMF will need Bank’s help to fulfil climate ambition

      15 Oct 2020
    5. Biden victory to boost Asia but China tensions to remain

      15 Oct 2020
  • Most viewed: GlobalMarkets

    1. Cambodia facing microfinance meltdown threat

  • Print
  • Latest news from GlobalMarkets

    1. EM debt pressures build as IMF calls for ‘early’ action on restructuring

      15 Oct 2020
    2. Post-Covid world will demand ‘new more humane’ capitalism

      15 Oct 2020
    3. IADB to roll out hurricane clauses as small state pleas gain traction

      15 Oct 2020
    4. IMF will need Bank’s help to fulfil climate ambition

      15 Oct 2020
    5. Biden victory to boost Asia but China tensions to remain

      15 Oct 2020
  • Most viewed: GlobalMarkets

    1. Cambodia facing microfinance meltdown threat

Further reading

  • Bryson hire reveals SMBC Nikko's capital markets ambitions

    Asia

    Bryson hire reveals SMBC Nikko's capital markets ambitions

  • Traders reluctant to 'chase’ covered bond spreads tighter

    Covered Bonds

    Traders reluctant to 'chase’ covered bond spreads tighter

  • Lendco brings first RMBS deal after market opens

    RMBS

    Lendco brings first RMBS deal after market opens

  • EU urged to use equity-like instruments to help smaller corporates

    Market News

    EU urged to use equity-like instruments to help smaller corporates

Global Capital

All material subject to strictly enforced copyright laws. © 2020 Euromoney Institutional Investor PLC group

About Us

  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Modern Slavery Act Transparency Statement

Connect with us

  • LinkedIn
  • @GlobalCapNews

Services

  • Advertise
  • Our partners
  • RSS
  • GlobalCapital Events
  • Events calendar
  • Social community

My Account

  • Renew
  • Subscribe
  • FAQ
  • Feedback
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies

Quick Links

  • All League Tables
  • Bank Profiles
  • Bond Comments
  • Deals & Deal Pipelines
  • Polls and Awards
  • GlobalCapital Archive
  • Special Reports Archive