A plea for prudent perp issuance – opinion

Asian borrowers have started selling perpetual bonds again, buoyed by hungry private bank buyers and at least a modicum of clarity around interest rates. But restraint is essential if they are to avoid a repeat of last year, when they pushed the perp structure to its limits and pulled the market down on their own heads.

  • By Lorraine Cushnie
  • 22 Jan 2014
Email a colleague
Request a PDF

Asian borrowers have typically had a shaky relationship with the perpetual asset class. The US and Europe are well populated by large utility and telecom companies for whom perpetual and hybrid perpetual bonds fit naturally into the capital structure. In Asia the experience has been a different one: Hutchison Whampoa’s €1.75bn non-call five blowout last year is certainly not the norm. In the Asian perp market, Chinese property companies have become just as common as global conglomerates.

This wouldn’t necessarily be a problem if issuers had either patience or prudence, and could be trusted to avoid pushing the market to breaking point. But they cannot. This time last year the perp market was already in trouble, as property companies tried to ram through deals with weak call incentives and meagre step-ups. That run of over-ambitious deals ended in bonds that sank in secondary, or were pulled before pricing.

By the time Ben Bernanke let the tapering cat out of the bag in May, supply had already come to an abrupt end. For the rest of 2013 Asian issuers sold only two perpetual bonds.

Things are different now. Tapering has started and, if you believe bankers, it’s already priced in. Investors certainly have more assurance of where interest rates are going to go, and packs of private bank buyers roam the bond market hungrily looking for things to buy.

Greentown Holdings got 2014 dollar perpetual issuance off to a strong start this week with a $500m non-call five year deal priced to yield 9%, and which offered a premium of just 125bp over than the B2 rated issuer’s senior curve. Last year borrowers were paying anything between 200bp and 400bp.

This makes Greentown a perfect advertisement for what your average Chinese property issuer can achieve in the bond market ­– equity treatment for IFRS accounting and a five year funding at a spread not that much higher that a senior bond.

Others are inevitably going to come, but the danger is that the step-ups start to drop, making structures more favourable to issuers and less so to investors. The market is already struggling under the weight of Chinese supply from all quarters and the last thing it needs is a non-call five perp from a double-B rated Chinese issuer with a 25bp first step-up at year 10. Agile Property, anyone?

It’s not just Chinese issuers that will suffer if they strangle the perp market, though. The Asian investor base, particularly the private banks, has a tendency to trade on the basis of asset class rather than name. When the perp market shuts for poor credits, it also makes it difficult for better ones — Chinese or not — that might well be natural candidates for perps.

Right now it looks like issuers have learned their lesson. Greentown’s bond came with a 500bp step-up at the first call date. For the high beta names at least, that's about where step-ups need to stay.

  • By Lorraine Cushnie
  • 22 Jan 2014

Panda Bonds Top Arrangers

Rank Arranger Share % by Volume
1 Bank of China (BOC) 18.01
2 Everbright Securities 16.95
3 Agricultural Bank of China (ABC) 10.59
4 HSBC 6.99
5 Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) 6.36

Bookrunners of Asia-Pac (ex-Japan) ECM

Rank Lead Manager Amount $m No of issues Share %
  • Last updated
  • 18 Jan 2017
1 Haitong Securities Ltd 1,602.34 9 13.94%
2 CITIC Securities 1,474.17 4 12.82%
3 China Securities Co Ltd 1,440.03 7 12.53%
4 Bank of China 1,188.86 5 10.34%
5 Guotai Junan Securities Co Ltd 689.79 3 6.00%

Bookrunners of Asia Pacific (ex-Japan) G3 DCM

Rank Lead Manager Amount $m No of issues Share %
  • Last updated
  • 18 Jan 2017
1 Citi 2,440.79 8 6.09%
2 HSBC 1,887.35 9 4.71%
3 JPMorgan 1,754.71 7 4.38%
4 Goldman Sachs 1,692.30 4 4.22%
5 Morgan Stanley 1,418.69 3 3.54%

Asian polls & awards

  • China Private Banking Awards 2017

    China’s private banking industry is growing in leaps and bounds. High- and ultra-high-net-worth mainland customers are increasingly mobile, demanding best-in-class service from their financial providers. Banks are adapting to the changing world, rolling out innovative and sophisticated services to their high-end clientele. In recognition of China’s advances in the field, Asiamoney is proud to announce the winners of its awards for best mainland private banks for 2016.

  • Corporate Governance Poll 2016: Time to get serious

    Asia has taken its time in improving corporate governance standards, with experts agreeing on the need for broader action. But Taiwan and Hong Kong firms seem to be moving in the right direction, as shown in the results of this year's Asiamoney Corporate Governance poll. Paolo Danese reports.

  • Best Managed Company Awards 2016: Asia’s finest stand out

    Asiamoney is pleased to present its choices for Asia’s Best Managed Companies in 2016. In a year marked by political and economic upheaval, the region’s best firms and executives impressed on through a combination of factors including financial performance, innovation and strategic execution.

  • Brokers Poll 2016: The right call

    Analysts in Asia are used to dealing with dynamic and unpredictable markets but the events of this year provided a real test of mettle. Against a backdrop of global political upheaval and worsening economic outlook at home, the winners of Asiamoney’s 2016 Brokers Poll have proved they have what it takes to impress their clients.

  • Brokers Poll 2016: HSBC and CLSA take the crown as Asia’s best

    Asia’s brokerages have needed to stay nimble in the face of volatile markets and changing regulation that has tested their industry. HSBC and CLSA are well placed to meet the challenge after coming out top in the Asiamoney Brokers Poll. Peter McGill reports.